Should the ECB's monetary policy be constrained by rules? An evaluation of the Fed's rules applied to the euro area.
Gillet, Noah
Promotor(s) :
Clerc, Pierrick
Date of defense : 31-Aug-2026/4-Sep-2026 • Permalink : http://hdl.handle.net/2268.2/27388
Details
| Title : | Should the ECB's monetary policy be constrained by rules? An evaluation of the Fed's rules applied to the euro area. |
| Translated title : | [fr] La politique monétaire de la BCE devrait-elle être contrainte par des règles ? Une évaluation des règles de la Fed appliquées à la zone euro. |
| Author : | Gillet, Noah
|
| Date of defense : | 31-Aug-2026/4-Sep-2026 |
| Advisor(s) : | Clerc, Pierrick
|
| Committee's member(s) : | Gautier, Axel
|
| Language : | English |
| Number of pages : | 59 |
| Keywords : | [en] Monetary policy rules [en] Taylor rule [en] European Central Bank [en] Federal Reserve [en] rules versus discretion [en] constrained discretion [en] euro area [en] unemployment gap [en] natural rate of interest [en] financial fragmentation [en] forward guidance [en] policy benchmarks |
| Discipline(s) : | Business & economic sciences > Macroeconomics & monetary economics |
| Target public : | Researchers Professionals of domain Student |
| Institution(s) : | Université de Liège, Liège, Belgique |
| Degree: | Master en sciences économiques, orientation générale, à finalité spécialisée en macroeconomics and finance |
| Faculty: | Master thesis of the HEC-Ecole de gestion de l'Université de Liège |
Abstract
[en] This thesis examines whether the European Central Bank’s monetary policy should be constrained by monetary policy rules. It applies the five simple policy rules currently presented in the Federal Reserve’s Monetary Policy Reports to euro area data over the period 2017Q1--2024Q4 and compares the resulting rule-implied rates with the ECB’s main refinancing operations rate. The results show that standard Taylor-type rules, especially the Taylor (1993) rule and the Balanced-Approach rules, prescribe policy rates far above the ECB’s actual rate during the 2022--2023 inflationary period, reaching around 13--14\%. From a strict Taylorian perspective, this could suggest that ECB policy was too accommodative. However, the analysis also shows that more flexible specifications, particularly the Adjusted Taylor rule and the First-Difference rule, provide closer approximations to the ECB’s observed policy path. The discussion argues that the ECB’s deviation from standard rules can be partly justified by the supply-side nature of the inflation shock, the resilience of the euro area labor market, and the institutional constraints of a heterogeneous monetary union. Nevertheless, the timing of the ECB’s initial tightening remains open to criticism. The thesis concludes that the ECB should not be mechanically constrained by standard Taylor-type rules, but could benefit from using rule-based benchmarks to make discretionary policy decisions more systematic, transparent, and accountable.
Cite this master thesis
The University of Liège does not guarantee the scientific quality of these students' works or the accuracy of all the information they contain.

Master Thesis Online


Noah_Gillet_THESIS_ENG.pdf